YouTube’s Neverending Copyright Battle

What could a fresh round of copyright issues mean for the future of the world’s second-most popular website?

Aug. 26, 2019

Last week, we witnessed the latest round in YouTube’s struggle to arbitrate between creators and copyright holders. The struggle is not well understood outside of the site’s community of users, but it may have major implications for the future of user-uploaded content on the web and it seems to have been going on forever.

In a blog post released on August 15th, the streaming giant, which has been owned by Google(NASDAQ: GOOG) since 2006, said that it will begin to crack down on the “aggressive manual claiming of very short music clips used in monetized videos” that has become a staple of the site. This effectively means that the company will make it harder for copyright holders to make claims against creators that are perceived as illegitimate or unfair, allowing uploaders to fight back to protect their revenue streams.

Check out If Big Tech Breaks Up, Which 3 Subsidaries Would We Invest In?

The new policy is based on a technique of disincentivization. In the past, a copyright holder such as a record label was given the opportunity to make money whenever some of its content was used in a monetized YouTube video, even if it was a fragment of music coming from a car in the background. Now, any company with a copyright complaint has the right to block a video but not to make money from it, which YouTube hopes will discourage predatory claims against unintentional infringements.

On the surface, it appears that YouTube is making a decisive stand in favor of the individuals and channels that have helped to secure its place very close to the top of global web rankings. However, the change may have unintended consequences for the platform and its creators as, although record labels can no longer make money from user-uploaded content, they may still choose to block videos entirely. 

Check out 15 Years On: Google’s 3 Best and Worst Acquisitions.

Founded in 2005 by Steve Chen, Jawed Karim, and Chad Hurley — all members of the so-called ‘PayPal Mafia’ — YouTube was a private startup for about a year before the famous $1.65 billion Google acquisition. At the time, it was one of the world’s fastest-growing websites and enjoyed a reputation as a fun and anarchic alternative to mainstream media. Today, YouTube is the second-most visited website in the U.S. after itself, as well as a media behemoth in its own right. (The quick transition from cool, punky startup to corporate giant somewhat reflects Facebook’s (NASDAQ: FB) rise to power).

All along the way, YouTube’s neverending copyright battle has plagued the company. With 300 hours of content uploaded every single minute, the site has been a nightmare (as well, no doubt, as a lucrative source of income) for traditional media outlets eager to pursue claims. In response to the scale of the problem, the company developed its well-known ‘Content ID’ system in 2007, which scans videos against a massive database of files for potential infringements. While the system certainly allows for more efficiency, it has also been criticized by creators for being opaque and unaccountable, powered by an irrefutable algorithm rather than sympathetic administrators and offering little opportunity to appeal.

These are not the only content problems YouTube is facing at the moment. For all its humorous channels, news outlets, and superstar entertainers, the platform also possesses a dark underside. From conspiracy theorists to political extremists — not to mention the disturbing proliferation of violent videos disguised as children’s shows — YouTube’s range of distressing content is so vast and diverse that the current algorithm cannot hope to suppress everything. CEO Susan Wojcicki has admitted as much, saying “It’s not like there is one lever we can pull and say, ‘Hey, let’s make all these changes,’ and everything would be solved.”

The company’s new policy will not actually make any significant changes to its ‘Content ID’ rules. Record labels will still be able to draw revenue from any video which the algorithm deems a copyright violation. However, by pressing its thumb on the scales in favor of its own community of creators, YouTube is showing the world that sometimes Silicon Valley’s big corporations will take a stand and safeguard the little guy.

MyWallSt operates a full disclosure policy. MyWallSt staff currently hold long positions in Alphabet and Facebook. Read our full disclosure policy here.